This is my first Cartier, and the moment you take it out of the box, you understand it's an icon for a reason. The square case, the screws, the whole look. But the more you actually use it, the crown and the clasp start working against you. So the question this review answers is simple. Can design alone carry a watch?
This is a 2008 Cartier Santos 100 Medium, reference W20106X8, with the silver dial on the original Cartier alligator strap.
The Case and Dial
The case is square, with the eight exposed screws on the bezel that the Santos is known for. The finishing is great. Everything about the design, up close, looks fantastic. Cartier knows design. There's no doubt about it.
The dial is silvered opaline with black Roman numerals and sword hands. If you look closely at the 7, the word Cartier is actually written into the numeral. The lume, on the other hand, is very minimal. It's not a strong lume by any standard.
The Crown
It's a pull-out crown. No screw-down, for the win. But this is a disappointing crown.
It has the blue cabochon on top, and there are two metal guards on either side of it. Those guards make it a pain to wind. It's harder to pull out than you'd expect, and the crown is kind of slippery. The first couple of winds are fine, and then you're really pressing hard between your fingers just to get enough grip to wind it.
I reviewed this right after the Jaeger-LeCoultre Polaris, which is the most gentle wind I've ever had. You just roll your finger across it. With this one, you're going, oh, come on.
Water resistance is 100 meters, and it's time only, with no date.
Price and What You Get
Cartier discontinued the Santos 100 when the new Santos de Cartier came out in 2018, so this one only trades on the secondary market now. Bernard Watch lists the retail on this reference at $6,850. Used, it normally trades between $4,000 and $4,800, and that range moves depending on what comes with it. This one comes with the box and the warranty papers.
The Strap and the Double Fold Clasp
It's on the original Cartier alligator strap, and I wouldn't swap it. It looks fantastic on this watch.
The clasp is the biggest thing I don't like. It's Cartier's older double fold clasp, used on Santos models before 2020, and there are no holes in the strap. You fold each end of the strap a full 180 degrees back around the clasp, and that's what holds it. It's simple, and I guess it's a tried and true method, but the first time I did it, I thought, there's no way this is going to hold.
I haven't had any issues with it, but I'm not the only one who's felt this way. I found a Santos 100 owner online asking how to stop his strap from slowly slipping out of this clasp. Strap makers also say the first sizing is a pain, though it looks great once it's set. And because the strap has to fold that far, only very thin straps will work with it, so it limits your options.
How the Santos 100 Medium Wears
At 33 millimeters wide and 10.7 millimeters thick, you'd think this would be tiny. A round 33 millimeter watch would look tiny on me. But the lugs are long, and it's 44.2 millimeters from lug to lug, so it wears much larger than a normal 33. It actually fits my 7 inch wrist quite well.
The Movement: Caliber 076
Inside is Cartier's caliber 076, which is based on an ETA 2671. It runs at 28,800 vibrations per hour, which is 8 beats per second, and has about 38 hours of power reserve. It's a basic movement, and it's not why you buy this watch.
The History Behind the Design
The design is why you buy this watch, and the design has real history. In 1904, Louis Cartier made the first Santos for his friend Alberto Santos-Dumont, a Brazilian aviator who wanted to read the time while he was flying without pulling out a pocket watch. It's considered one of the first men's wristwatches ever made, and Cartier started selling it to the public in 1911.
The Santos 100 came out in 2004 to celebrate 100 years of that design. The ones made in that first year even have 1904 to 2004 engraved on the case back.
Cartier Santos 100 vs Rolex Datejust
The watch people compare this to all the time is a smooth bezel Rolex Datejust 36. That's the buyer who wants a really well-designed everyday watch and is deciding between Rolex and Cartier. The Datejust has the better movement, it has a date, and it's going to hold its value better. The Santos wins on design, and it gives you a completely different look on the wrist.
Verdict: Can Design Alone Carry a Watch?
With the Santos, it pretty much does. It hits every mark on design, and it gets almost nothing else.
If I could change one thing about this watch, it would be the clasp. I'd want something I don't have to second guess every time I put it on.
Aesthetics & Heritage — 32/50
- Styling: 9
- Movement & Craftsmanship: 5
- Cool Factor: 6
- Legacy: 8
- Value & Collectibility: 4
Wearability & Utility — 25/50
- Comfort: 7
- Usability & Tactility: 3
- Features & Complications: 3
- Build Quality: 6
- Versatility: 6
Total: 57/100
That ties the Santos with the Tudor Black Bay 58 Burgundy, right behind the Panerai Luminor Base 44 and just ahead of the Breitling Superocean Automatic 44.
Who should buy it: If design is why you're buying a watch, this is for you. I think every collector should have a Santos in their rotation at some point, because it gives you a different look on the wrist that nothing else does. It doesn't have to be this exact Santos 100.
Who should pass: If you care about how a crown winds, a clasp you can trust, or the movement inside, I'd pass.
Where to Find One
If you're looking for this reference, feel free to send us a message. We may still have this exact watch in our inventory. Or if this one's already been sold, we can always find one just like it for you.
You can also sign up for the 5D Insider email list. You get better pricing, you get first look at new inventory, and you get a heads up any time a watch goes live or I go live on a no reserve auction. You'll also get watch news and a weekly update.
Frequently Asked Questions
What size is the Cartier Santos 100 Medium W20106X8?
The case is about 33 millimeters wide, 44.2 millimeters from lug to lug, and 10.7 millimeters thick. Because of the long lugs, it wears much larger than a round 33 millimeter watch and fits a 7 inch wrist well.
Is the Cartier Santos 100 discontinued?
Yes. Cartier discontinued the Santos 100 when it launched the new Santos de Cartier in 2018. The Santos 100 now only trades on the secondary market.
How much is a used Cartier Santos 100 W20106X8 worth?
Bernard Watch lists the retail on this reference at $6,850. Used, it normally trades between $4,000 and $4,800, depending on what comes with it, such as the box and warranty papers.
How does the Cartier Santos 100 clasp work?
The Santos 100 uses Cartier's older double fold clasp. The strap has no holes. Each end folds a full 180 degrees back around the clasp, and that fold is what holds the strap in place.
Can the strap slip out of the Santos 100 clasp?
Some owners have reported straps slowly slipping out of this style of clasp, since there's no pin or tongue holding the strap. I haven't had any issues with mine, but it's worth checking the fit each time you put it on.
What movement is in the Cartier Santos 100 Medium?
It uses Cartier's caliber 076, an automatic movement based on the ETA 2671. It runs at 28,800 vibrations per hour, which is 8 beats per second, with about 38 hours of power reserve.
Is the Cartier Santos 100 water resistant?
Yes. The Santos 100 Medium W20106X8 is water resistant to 100 meters, and the case back is marked 100M.
Why is it called the Santos?
Louis Cartier made the first Santos in 1904 for his friend Alberto Santos-Dumont, a Brazilian aviator who wanted to read the time while flying. The Santos 100 launched in 2004 for the design's 100th anniversary.
Is there a hidden Cartier signature on the Santos 100 dial?
Yes. Look closely at the Roman numeral VII, and the word Cartier is written into the numeral.
Cartier Santos 100 or Rolex Datejust?
The Datejust has the better movement, a date, and holds its value better. The Santos wins on design and gives you a completely different look on the wrist.
What is the 5D Score of the Cartier Santos 100?
It scores 57 out of 100: 32 out of 50 for Aesthetics and Heritage and 25 out of 50 for Wearability and Utility.